Fleet Insurance Quote Comparison Sheet – Compare More Than the Price
Put up to three fleet insurance quotes side by side. The sheet highlights every difference in cover, driver basis, excess and extras, flags anything one quote leaves out, and prints neatly so you can share it before you decide.
- Compare up to three quotes
- Spots missing cover and extras
- Free, with no sign-up
Quick answerThe cheapest fleet quote is not always the best value. Compare the cover level, who can drive, the minimum driver age, every excess and the extras each quote includes. A lower premium with a higher excess, or without breakdown or legal cover, can cost more when you claim.
Free tool
Line Up Your Fleet Quotes
Fill in what each quote offers. Rows that differ turn amber, and the summary shows what stands out.
| What to compare | Quote A | Quote B | Quote C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Broker or insurer | |||
| Annual premium | |||
| Total if paying monthlyLeave blank if paying annually | |||
| Cover level | |||
| Driver basis | |||
| Youngest driver age allowed | |||
| Compulsory excess | |||
| Voluntary excess | |||
| Young or new driver excess | |||
| Windscreen cover | |||
| Courtesy or replacement vehicle | |||
| Breakdown cover | |||
| Legal expenses | |||
| Goods in transit | |||
| Hire and reward included | |||
| Driving abroad | |||
| Telematics required | |||
| Other conditions or limitse.g. overnight parking rules |
How it works
How to Compare Fleet Quotes Fairly
Three steps, using the quote documents from each broker or insurer.
Gather the documents
Use each quote and its policy summary. Look for the excesses, driver rules and what is included.
Fill in the sheet
Add the details for each quote. Leave anything you are unsure of blank and ask the broker.
Check the differences
Look at the highlighted rows and the flags, then ask brokers to match cover before comparing price.
Worked example
Three Quotes, One Clear Choice
Made-up figures to show how the sheet works. Use "Load an example" in the tool to see them.
| Detail | Broker A | Broker B | Broker C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual premium | £6,200 | £5,850 | £6,400 |
| Excess | £500 | £1,000 | £500 |
| Driver basis | Any driver | Named drivers | Any driver |
| Courtesy vehicle | Yes | No | Yes |
| Breakdown cover | No | No | Yes |
Broker B is cheapest, but its excess is £500 higher, it only covers named drivers and it has no courtesy vehicle. If you need any driver cover, A and C are the like-for-like choices, and C includes breakdown cover for £200 more.
Method
How the Sheet Spots Differences
There is no hidden scoring. The sheet only compares what you type in.
Differences
A row turns amber when the quotes you have filled in do not all match.
Flags
The summary lists extras one quote includes and another leaves out, and warns when cover levels or driver rules differ.
Private
Nothing is saved or sent. Use "Print or save as PDF" to keep a copy.
Next steps
More Free Fleet Tools
Two quotes with different excesses? Not sure which driver basis you need? These tools help.
Fleet insurance excess calculator
Compare two quotes with different excesses and find the number of claims at which the cheaper premium stops being cheaper.
- Break-even number of claims
- Cost at 0 to 5 claims
- Quick to use
Named or any driver checker
Answer six quick questions about who drives your vehicles and see whether named, specified or any driver cover is likely to suit.
- Six quick questions
- Reasons explained
- No prices or sign-up
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
Questions about comparing fleet insurance quotes.
Using the sheet4 questions
What does the fleet quote comparison sheet do?
It lets you enter up to three fleet quotes side by side, highlights every detail that differs and flags cover or extras that one quote includes and another leaves out.
Where do I find the details to enter?
In each quote and its policy summary or key facts document. If something is not clear, ask the broker before you compare.
Can I save my comparison?
Use "Print or save as PDF" to keep a copy. The sheet does not save or send what you type.
Does the sheet tell me which quote to choose?
No. It shows the differences so you can decide what matters to your business. The right choice depends on the cover you need, not just the price.
Comparing fleet quotes4 questions
What should I compare apart from the price?
The level of cover, who can drive and from what age, every excess, the extras included, any conditions such as overnight parking or telematics, and how claims are handled.
Why are my fleet quotes so different?
Insurers rate vehicles, drivers, business use and claims records differently, and quotes often include different extras and excesses. Comparing like for like shows the real difference.
Should I ask brokers to match cover?
Yes. If one quote includes something you need and another does not, ask the second broker to quote with it included so you can compare fairly.
How many fleet quotes should I get?
There is no set number, but comparing several helps. You can compare fleet quotes from specialist UK brokers with one enquiry.
Ready when you are
Compare Fleet Insurance Quotes Today
Answer a few questions about your business, vehicles and drivers, and specialist UK fleet brokers can get in touch with quotes. It's free to use, with no obligation to buy.
- Specialist UK fleet brokers
- Cars, vans, HGVs and mixed fleets
- FCA authorised and regulated
Free to use · Minimum 2 vehicles · No obligation
Why MyMoneyComparison.com
Who Is Behind This Tool?
MyMoneyComparison.com is an FCA-authorised UK comparison website, founded in 2013, that connects businesses with specialist UK fleet brokers through one fleet insurance comparison form. The service is free to use and there is no obligation to accept a quote.
Specialist fleet brokers
Reach a specialist fleet insurance broker for cars, vans, HGVs and mixed fleets.
Form for your whole fleet
Describe your business, vehicles and drivers once instead of repeating yourself to each broker.
Authorised and regulated
MyMoneyComparison.com Ltd appears on the FCA register under FRN 916241.
Incorporated
Helping UK drivers and businesses compare insurance for over a decade.
About this page
We built this fleet insurance quote comparison sheet to help UK businesses make better decisions about fleet insurance. It is a guide based on the information you enter, not a quote or advice. Cover, eligibility and price vary by insurer, so compare real quotes and read the policy documents before buying.
How we build and check this tool
- The calculations are set out in full on this page, so you can check them yourself
- Every figure comes from what you enter. We do not add estimated premiums
- Facts about MOTs, licences and tax are checked against GOV.UK
- Reviewed by Michael Harrington before publication and at each review date
- The tool runs in your browser and does not send what you type to us
This page is written by Sarah Hampton, Insurance Specialist at MyMoneyComparison.com, and checked by a named reviewer before it is published. The reviewer, their credentials and the review dates are set out on this page.
Fleet insurance library
Guides and cover types
Twelve guides covering the whole buying journey, and every kind of fleet we arrange cover for. Each guide is checked before publication.