Fleet Insurance Excess Calculator – When Does a Lower Premium Stop Paying?
Compare two fleet quotes with different premiums and excesses. The calculator shows what each costs at your expected number of claims, the break-even point, and the total cost at zero to five claims a year.
- Break-even number of claims
- Cost at 0 to 5 claims
- Free, with no sign-up
Quick answerA cheaper fleet quote with a higher excess is only better value if you make few claims. Divide the difference in premium by the difference in excess to find the break-even number of claims a year. Make fewer claims than that and the cheaper premium wins.
Free tool
Compare Premium and Excess
Enter each quote's premium and total excess per claim, then how many claims you expect.
How it works
How to Use the Excess Calculator
You need two quotes and a sensible estimate of how many claims you make.
Enter both quotes
Add the annual premium and the total excess per claim for each, including any voluntary excess.
Estimate your claims
Use your own claims record. The claims experience calculator can help.
Read the break-even
If you expect fewer claims than the break-even number, the lower premium is better value.
Worked example
A £500 Saving, Tested
Made-up figures to show the maths. Use "Load the worked example" in the tool.
| Claims a year | Quote A: £6,200, £500 excess | Quote B: £5,700, £1,000 excess |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | £6,200 | £5,700 |
| 1 | £6,700 | £6,700 |
| 2 | £7,200 | £7,700 |
| 3 | £7,700 | £8,700 |
The break-even is one claim a year (£500 premium difference ÷ £500 excess difference). With 1.5 claims a year expected, Quote A costs £250 less.
Method
How the Calculator Works It Out
These are the sums the calculator runs every time you change a figure.
Break-even claims = (premium B − premium A) ÷ (excess A − excess B)
Small claims
If a claim would cost less than the excess, you would not claim at all, so the excess matters less for minor damage.
Your record matters too
Each claim can also affect your premium at renewal, which the calculator does not include.
Different excesses
Young driver, windscreen and theft excesses can differ from the main excess. Compare those too.
Next steps
More Free Fleet Tools
Comparing more than excess and price? Check your claims record and line up every detail.
Fleet insurance quote comparison sheet
Put up to three fleet quotes side by side and see where the cover, excess and extras differ, not just the price.
- Highlights every difference
- Flags missing cover
- Print or save as PDF
Fleet claims experience calculator
Work out your loss ratio, claims per vehicle and average claim, with a plain-English read of how insurers may see your record.
- Up to five policy years
- Shows the trend year by year
- Ready for renewal talks
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
Questions about fleet insurance excesses.
Using the calculator4 questions
What does the excess calculator do?
It compares two quotes with different premiums and excesses, shows the total cost at your expected number of claims and finds the break-even point.
What is the break-even number of claims?
The number of claims a year at which both quotes cost the same. Below it, the lower premium is cheaper. Above it, the lower excess is cheaper.
How many claims should I expect?
Use your own claims record over the last three to five years. Divide the number of claims by the number of years for a yearly average.
Is anything I enter saved?
No. The calculator works in your browser and does not save or send anything.
Fleet excesses4 questions
What is an excess on fleet insurance?
The amount you pay towards each claim. It is usually made up of a compulsory excess set by the insurer and any voluntary excess you choose.
Does a higher excess lower the premium?
Usually, yes, because you take on more of the cost of each claim. Whether it is worth it depends on how often you claim.
Are there different excesses for different drivers?
Often. Young or inexperienced drivers commonly have an extra excess, and windscreen or theft claims may have their own.
Can I recover my excess?
If a claim was not your fault, your insurer may recover your excess from the other driver's insurer.
Ready when you are
Compare Fleet Insurance Quotes Today
Answer a few questions about your business, vehicles and drivers, and specialist UK fleet brokers can get in touch with quotes. It's free to use, with no obligation to buy.
- Specialist UK fleet brokers
- Cars, vans, HGVs and mixed fleets
- FCA authorised and regulated
Free to use · Minimum 2 vehicles · No obligation
Why MyMoneyComparison.com
Who Is Behind This Tool?
MyMoneyComparison.com is an FCA-authorised UK comparison website, founded in 2013, that connects businesses with specialist UK fleet brokers through one fleet insurance comparison form. The service is free to use and there is no obligation to accept a quote.
Specialist fleet brokers
Reach a specialist fleet insurance broker for cars, vans, HGVs and mixed fleets.
Form for your whole fleet
Describe your business, vehicles and drivers once instead of repeating yourself to each broker.
Authorised and regulated
MyMoneyComparison.com Ltd appears on the FCA register under FRN 916241.
Incorporated
Helping UK drivers and businesses compare insurance for over a decade.
About this page
We built this fleet insurance excess calculator to help UK businesses make better decisions about fleet insurance. It is a guide based on the information you enter, not a quote or advice. Cover, eligibility and price vary by insurer, so compare real quotes and read the policy documents before buying.
How we build and check this tool
- The calculations are set out in full on this page, so you can check them yourself
- Every figure comes from what you enter. We do not add estimated premiums
- Facts about MOTs, licences and tax are checked against GOV.UK
- Reviewed by Michael Harrington before publication and at each review date
- The tool runs in your browser and does not send what you type to us
This page is written by Sarah Hampton, Insurance Specialist at MyMoneyComparison.com, and checked by a named reviewer before it is published. The reviewer, their credentials and the review dates are set out on this page.
Fleet insurance library
Guides and cover types
Twelve guides covering the whole buying journey, and every kind of fleet we arrange cover for. Each guide is checked before publication.