Skip to content

Fleet vs Individual Insurance Calculator – Would One Policy Cost Less?

Add what you pay to insure each vehicle separately, then a fleet quote, and the calculator shows which costs less over a year once admin time and fees are counted. If you do not have a fleet quote yet, it shows the most a fleet policy could cost and still save you money.

  • Uses your own premiums, not averages
  • Counts admin time and policy fees
  • Free, with no sign-up

Quick answerFleet insurance is not always cheaper than separate policies, but it often costs less once you count the time spent managing several renewals. Add up what each vehicle costs to insure, plus fees and admin time, and compare that total with a fleet quote plus its own admin. If the fleet total is lower, one policy saves you money.

Free calculator

Compare Your Separate Policies With a Fleet Quote

Enter the yearly premium for each vehicle, check the admin assumptions, then add your fleet quote. Everything is worked out in your browser as you type.

1Your separate policies today

Add each vehicle and what its own policy costs a year. Use your renewal notices or quotes.

2The hidden cost of separate policies

Our starting figures are assumptions. Change them to match your business, or set them to 0.

Admin or arrangement fees
Renewals, changes, paperwork
Wages and overheads
3Your fleet quote

Leave the premium blank to see the most a fleet policy could cost and still save you money.

One policy and renewal

How it works

How to Use the Fleet vs Individual Calculator

Three steps, using figures from your own renewal notices and quotes. It takes a few minutes for a small fleet.

  1. List your vehicles

    Add each vehicle and the yearly premium on its own policy. Your renewal notices or online account will show it.

  2. Count the hidden costs

    Set any fees per policy and how many hours a year each policy takes to renew and update. Change our starting figures to suit you.

  3. Add a fleet quote

    Enter a fleet quote to see the difference, or leave it blank to see your break-even fleet premium before you ask for quotes.

Worked example

A Four-Vehicle Business, Worked Through

Made-up figures to show the maths, not typical prices. Use the "Load the worked example" link in the calculator to see them filled in.

Separate policies compared with a fleet quote
ItemSeparate policiesFleet policy
Premiums£5,230 (three vans and a car)£4,600
Fees£100 (4 × £25)£25
Admin time at £20 an hour£160 (8 hours)£80 (4 hours)
Total for the year£5,490£4,705

In this example the fleet policy saves about £785 a year, or £196 per vehicle. The break-even fleet premium is £5,385: any fleet quote below that would still save money once the fleet's own fees and admin are counted.

Method

How the Calculator Works Out Your Figures

Nothing is hidden. These are the sums the calculator runs every time you change a figure.

Separate total = sum of premiums + (policies × fee) + (policies × admin hours × hourly cost)
Fleet total = fleet premium + fleet fees + (fleet admin hours × hourly cost)
Difference = separate total − fleet total
Break-even fleet premium = separate total − fleet fees − (fleet admin hours × hourly cost)

What it includes

Premiums, policy fees and the cost of the time your team spends renewing and updating policies.

What it leaves out

Differences in cover, excesses, drivers allowed and claims service. A cheaper policy that covers less is not a saving.

Your claims record

Fleet policies are priced on the whole fleet and its claims history, so a fleet quote can move more at renewal than a single policy.

Next steps

More Free Fleet Tools

Once you know a fleet policy could work, plan the renewal and budget for the full year. Our guide to whether fleet insurance is cheaper than separate policies explains the reasons behind the numbers.

Free tool

Fleet insurance renewal planner

Keep renewal, MOT, service, road tax and licence check dates in one calendar, with a reminder to compare quotes in good time.

  • Overdue and upcoming at a glance
  • Add to Google, Outlook or Apple calendar
  • Saved on your device only
Plan my renewals
Free tool

Fleet insurance cost calculator

Turn a quote or renewal notice into a full-year budget, including mid-term changes, excesses and the cost of paying monthly.

  • Monthly and per-vehicle figures
  • Plans for vehicles joining and leaving
  • No invented prices
Budget my fleet cover

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions

Questions about using the calculator, and about choosing between one fleet policy and separate policies.

Using the calculator5 questions

What does the fleet vs individual insurance calculator do?

It adds up what you spend a year insuring each vehicle separately, including fees and admin time, and compares that with a fleet quote plus its own admin. It also shows the break-even fleet premium, the most a fleet policy could cost and still save you money.

Where do I find the figures to enter?

Each vehicle's yearly premium is on its renewal notice, schedule or online account. For the fleet premium, use a quote from a broker or insurer. You can compare fleet quotes through us for free.

Why does the calculator include admin time?

Each separate policy has its own renewal, paperwork and changes. That time costs the business money, so leaving it out makes separate policies look cheaper than they really are. Set the hours to 0 if you would rather leave it out.

What is the break-even fleet premium?

It is the highest fleet premium that would still cost you less overall than your separate policies, after the fleet policy's own fees and admin. Any quote below it saves money on your figures.

Is what I enter saved or sent anywhere?

No. The calculator works in your browser and does not send or store what you type. Refreshing the page clears it.

Fleet or separate policies?5 questions

Is fleet insurance always cheaper than separate policies?

No. It depends on your vehicles, drivers, business use and claims record. Fleet policies are often easier to manage, and the saving in admin can tip the balance, which is why the calculator includes it.

How many vehicles do I need for fleet insurance?

Many insurers offer fleet cover from two or more vehicles, and some set a higher minimum. Smaller businesses can also look at mini fleet insurance.

What happens to my no claims discount if I move to a fleet?

Some insurers will take your vehicles' no claims history into account when setting up a new fleet, and a fleet then builds its own claims record. Ask for proof of no claims from your current insurers before you switch. Our guide to fleet no claims discount explains more.

Should I compare cover as well as price?

Yes. Check the level of cover, who can drive, the excess and any limits are the same before comparing totals. A lower price for less cover is not a like-for-like saving.

Can I put cars and vans on the same fleet policy?

Usually, yes. Many fleet policies cover a mix of cars, vans and other vehicles, subject to the insurer's criteria. See mixed fleet insurance.

Ready when you are

Compare Fleet Insurance Quotes Today

Answer a few questions about your business, vehicles and drivers, and specialist UK fleet brokers can get in touch with quotes. It's free to use, with no obligation to buy.

  • Specialist UK fleet brokers
  • Cars, vans, HGVs and mixed fleets
  • FCA authorised and regulated

Free to use · Minimum 2 vehicles · No obligation

Why MyMoneyComparison.com

Who Is Behind This Tool?

MyMoneyComparison.com is an FCA-authorised UK comparison website, founded in 2013, that connects businesses with specialist UK fleet brokers through one fleet insurance comparison form. The service is free to use and there is no obligation to accept a quote.

UK

Specialist fleet brokers

Reach a specialist fleet insurance broker for cars, vans, HGVs and mixed fleets.

1

Form for your whole fleet

Describe your business, vehicles and drivers once instead of repeating yourself to each broker.

FCA

Authorised and regulated

MyMoneyComparison.com Ltd appears on the FCA register under FRN 916241.

2013

Incorporated

Helping UK drivers and businesses compare insurance for over a decade.

Sources

Sources and Research

The facts this tool relies on come from these publications. We link to the specific page and check each one before the tool is published.

  1. HM Revenue and CustomsInsurance Premium Tax ratesGOV.UK, checked November 2026. Used for: The standard rate of Insurance Premium Tax, 12%, which is normally included in the premium you are quoted.
  2. Association of British Insurers (ABI)£11.9 billion paid out in 2025 to support motorists across 2.5 million claimsPublished February 2026. Used for: Why claims and repair costs move premiums from one year to the next.

About this page

We built this calculator to help UK businesses see whether one fleet policy would cost less than insuring each vehicle separately. It is a guide based on the figures you enter, not a quote or advice. Cover, eligibility and price vary by insurer, so compare real quotes and read the policy documents before buying.

How we build and check this tool

  • The calculations are set out in full on this page, so you can check them yourself
  • Every figure comes from what you enter. We do not add estimated premiums
  • Facts about MOTs, licences and tax are checked against GOV.UK
  • Reviewed by Michael Harrington before publication and at each review date
  • The tool runs in your browser and does not send what you type to us

This page is written by Sarah Hampton, Insurance Specialist at MyMoneyComparison.com, and checked by a named reviewer before it is published. The reviewer, their credentials and the review dates are set out on this page.