Leasehold buildings insurance commission is one reason block of flats insurance costs so much, and since the end of 2023 leaseholders have had the right to see it. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) found that premiums for blocks had more than doubled in five years, and that commission was often a large slice of the price. This guide sets out what the FCA found, what leaseholders can now ask for, and what freeholders and resident management companies need to have ready.
Key points
- The FCA found mean premiums for mid and high-rise blocks rose by 125% between 2016 and 2021.
- In most cases it looked at, commission was at least 30% of the premium.
- Since 31 December 2023, leaseholders can ask for the commission paid, in pounds, and how the policy was chosen.
- The FCA has not capped commission, but policies must offer fair value to leaseholders.
- The government plans to set out which insurance fees can be passed on to leaseholders; no start date has been set.
How much have block of flats insurance premiums risen?
In its September 2022 report on insurance for multi-occupancy buildings, the FCA found that the mean premium across the mid and high-rise blocks in its sample rose by 125% between 2016 and 2021. Blocks with flammable cladding saw the steepest rises, but premiums for blocks without it still almost doubled.
Mean annual premium, mid and high-rise blocks
| Blocks in the FCA sample | 2016 | 2021 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| All blocks | £6,800 | £15,300 | +125% |
| With identified flammable cladding | £26,300 | £75,600 | +187% |
| Without identified flammable cladding | £6,700 | £13,000 | +94% |
Source: FCA, Report on insurance for multi-occupancy buildings, September 2022. The FCA notes its data are incomplete and weighted towards individually insured or small-portfolio buildings.
Part of that rise reflects real risk: fire safety concerns, rebuild costs and a smaller pool of insurers willing to cover some buildings. But the FCA also looked at what happened to the money on its way from the leaseholder to the insurer.
How much of the premium is commission?
Commission is paid by the insurer to the broker who arranges the policy, and the broker may share part of it with the freeholder or managing agent. The FCA found that in most cases it analysed, commission was at least 30% of the premium, with rates ranging from under 10% to 62%.
Rising premiums also meant rising commission in cash terms. For blocks with flammable cladding, the mean value of commission kept by brokers more than tripled between 2016 and 2021, even though the percentage rate fell slightly.
A follow-up FCA review of broker remuneration, published in April 2023, looked in detail at 16 firms. Of the £216.1 million they earned in commission, £80.7 million, or 37%, was paid on to third parties, mainly freeholders, property managing agents and introducers. Eight of the firms paid more than half of their commission to a third party.
What changed for leaseholders on 31 December 2023?
The FCA’s rules for multi-occupancy buildings insurance came into force on 31 December 2023. They treat residential leaseholders as customers whose interests insurers and brokers must consider, even though the freeholder or management company buys the policy.
A leaseholder can now ask the insurer or broker for:
- a summary of the cover, including excesses and exclusions;
- a breakdown of the premium, including insurance premium tax;
- the commission and any other payments made, including amounts passed to the freeholder or managing agent, shown in pounds rather than as a percentage;
- how many alternative quotes the broker obtained, and why the chosen policy suits the leaseholders;
- any conflicts of interest the broker has.
If the freeholder or managing agent does not pass this information on, the firm has to provide it to the leaseholder directly. The rules do not cap or ban commission. Instead, products must offer fair value to leaseholders, and the FCA has said that earnings that rise only because premiums rise would not meet that test.
What comes next for insurance fees?
The government has also looked at what landlords and managing agents can charge leaseholders for arranging insurance. Its consultation on permitted insurance fees ran from December 2024 to February 2025, and it published its response on 11 July 2025.
The plan is to allow only a fair and transparent fee for the work involved, with the detail set out in future rules. The government has said it will keep working with the industry on what activities and pay are proportionate, and no start date has been set. Until then, the FCA disclosure rules are the main tool leaseholders have.
What this means for freeholders and resident management companies
For anyone who arranges insurance for a block, whether a freeholder, a resident management company or a right to manage company, the practical effect is that leaseholders can see more than before. It is worth assuming every figure will be read.
- Keep the information to hand. Ask your broker for the leaseholder information at each renewal, so requests can be answered quickly.
- Be ready to explain any share of commission. If the freeholder or managing agent receives part of the commission, be clear about what work it pays for.
- Keep evidence of shopping around. The number of alternative quotes is part of what leaseholders can ask for.
- Work on the risk as well as the price. Leaks, fire safety records, cladding and the rebuild figure all affect what insurers charge. The block of flats insurance page explains which block details insurers look at most closely.
Blocks with shops, offices or other commercial units on the ground floor may need a policy written for mixed use. Our commercial property insurance page covers flats above shops and other mixed-use buildings.
Reviewing your block’s insurance at renewal?
Comparing quotes is the clearest evidence that a block policy offers fair value. MyMoneyComparison.com introduces freeholders, resident management companies and landlords to specialist UK brokers. It is free to use, with no obligation to buy.
Questions leaseholders can ask about their buildings insurance
- Who is the insurer, and who is the broker?
- What does the policy cover, and what are the excesses?
- How much of the premium is insurance premium tax?
- How much commission was paid, in pounds, and to whom?
- Was any of it passed to the freeholder or managing agent, and what was it for?
- How many alternative quotes were obtained before renewal?
- Why was this policy chosen over the others?
- Has the premium changed because of claims, cladding or the rebuild figure?
Our guide to comparing specialist insurance properly explains how to set quotes side by side on cover, conditions and excess as well as price.
Leasehold buildings insurance commission questions
Is commission on block of flats insurance allowed?
Yes. The FCA has not banned or capped commission, but insurers and brokers must make sure the policy offers fair value to leaseholders, and earnings that rise only because premiums rise would not meet that test.
Can I find out how much commission was paid on my building’s insurance?
Since 31 December 2023, residential leaseholders can ask for the commission and other payments made, shown in pounds, including any amount passed to the freeholder or managing agent.
Who do I ask for the information?
Start with the freeholder or managing agent. If they do not pass the information on, the insurer or broker has to provide it to you directly.
Why has my block’s premium risen if it has no cladding?
The FCA found that premiums for blocks without identified flammable cladding still rose by 94% between 2016 and 2021. Rebuild costs, claims such as leaks, fire safety records and the number of insurers willing to cover a building all play a part.
Do the FCA rules apply to commercial tenants?
No. The disclosure rules apply to residential leaseholders in multi-occupancy buildings.
Sources
- FCA, Report on insurance for multi-occupancy buildings, September 2022
- FCA, Multi-occupancy buildings insurance: broker remuneration, April 2023
- FCA, PS23/14: Multi-occupancy building insurance final rules, September 2023
- Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, permitted insurance fees consultation and response, July 2025
Commercial property insuranceCompare quotes →
How to compare specialist insuranceRead the guide →
This guide is general information about UK leasehold buildings insurance, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Figures are taken from the sources listed and were correct when checked in November 2026.

